Sitka spruce vs adirondack spruce. I've seen a few sites on line that state, Ad.
Sitka spruce vs adirondack spruce. Sitka hat verschiedene Vorteile.
Sitka spruce vs adirondack spruce It is often compared to Adirondack, or red, spruce. I just purchased a 2015 Gibson L-00 Red Spruce Limited guitar. The trouble is, when a builder has a couple of pieces of spruce, they are specific, not average. Adirondack Tops General Acoustic Guitar Discussion The Acoustic Guitar Based on it stiffness, I use Adirondack Spruce for my bracing material no matter what top is used (cedar included. But honestly, I Two in particular, the Adirondack Spruce[Red Spruce from the Adirondack region of upstate New York] and the Sitka Spruce, are beloved by guitar makers as they produce the Compared to Sitka and Engelmann spruce, Adirondack spruce enjoys a long historical reputation. Sitka vs adirondack spuce top - Martin D28 Comparison- Which sounds better? Martin D28 Sitka top Vs D28 Marquis with an Adirondack top LET ME KNOW YOUR COMME Yes, the average for one type may be a bit this way or that way from the others, and hence we wind up with all this Adirondack vs. Also, it depends on what kind of music will be played. Sitka Spruce By Brent Cole | March 7, 2016 Adirondack Spruce vs. Posts: 555 I've owned a ton of Adi topped guitars and most of them were great My solid-Sitka-spruce-topped Yamaha FG730S (dread) is louder and brighter sounding than my solid-Engleman-spruce-topped Yamaha LS-6 (OM/000). The Queets Spruce, located in Olympic National Park, is the largest Sitka spruce in the world with a trunk diameter of 14. Big, old trees offer a high yield to the sawyer, and supply and demand being what it is, high yield means low price. e. Adirondack is bolder, but takes breaking in. The Adirondack and Engelmann tops are louder and more distinct than MORE INFO: Give us a call at (406) 290-9390 or email us at sales@musicvilla. When it comes to high-end acoustic guitars, the soundboard, often made of spruce, plays a crucial role in shaping the instrument's voice. I haven't played any yet. If you're on the hunt for your dream acoustic, I have several Sitka (three dreads, one OM, one 000), one Adirondack GC and one Engelmann custom built 12 fret SS dread. Post Nov 01, 2001 #1 2001-11-01T06:20+00:00. I can clearly hear and feel the difference in sound with cedar. Jr. 55 m) at breast height, trunk volume of 11,900 cu ft (337 m 3), and a height of 248 ft (75. To me, at least on paper, a red spruce top is not necessarily worth an additional $1000 in the overall cost of a guitar. Generally more expensive than sitka (especially master grade tight grained, perfectly quartered, silked, Today we compare Adirondack Spruce vs Sitka Spruce tops on 2 identical Martin HD-28 models. Therefore, it is available in high grades despite the quantity used. Meistens ist es billiger als Adirondack, der Klang ist immer schön ausgewogen, warm, braucht weniger Zeit zum Entwickeln und ist fast sofort ein Freund fürs Leben. Posts: 6,200 Sitka spruce VS Adirondack to accompany vocals General Acoustic Guitar Discussion The Sitka vs. Cedar would be lighter than Englemann, and Redwood is heavier than Cedar, but also has a wide range. Adirondack or Sitka? General Acoustic Guitar Discussion The Acoustic Guitar I've sold off everything else: Torrefied Adirondack, German Spruce, Carpathian. The same properties as Adirondack, controlled via density – i. And between sitka and red spruce there is a great deal of overlap in terms of stiffness, so that some sitka is stiffer than some red spruce and vice versa. Skip to main content FREE SHIPPING ON aesthetic purity of look (they tend to be wider-grained and more irregular in color and grain patterns), but tonally, Adirondack is even more dynamic than Sitka, Adirondack Spruce vs. Location: Forest Both guitars are from Hozen Guitars, a Singaporean boutique guitar brand focused on the intricacies and the responsiveness of instruments. 4 m Red spruce and Sitka have almost the same density (which they are calling weight), although red spruce is shown as having a marginally higher specific Eastern red spruce: Commonly referred to as Adirondack spruce, this tonewood is slightly heavier and stiffer than Sitka spruce. Looooove this article, could you please make a similar one with Adirondack Quoting Martin "Carpathian spruce blends the power and clarity of Adirondack spruce, with the warmth and responsiveness of Italian alpine spruce". The bass is generally not as warm as the bass on Euro or Sitka. In my personal opinion, there are so many more similarities than differences between the two woods. Member; Posts: 98; 2018 Custom GA - bear claw sitka spruce/mahogany 2019 614 - torrified sitka spruce/flamed maple 2020 714 - lutz spruce/rosewood. Registered Member. Spruce trees are widespread in the wild, with over 40 different species known to exist. Which do you think sounds best the traditional (sitka) or the up I have two guitars with Adirondack tops and all the rest are either western red cedar or sitka spruce. I do build them with Adirondack. But your top has the VTS treatment so that does change the game. Spruce is known for its excellent stiffness-to-weight ratio, which translates into a bright, articulate, and Sitka Spruce. I've seen a few sites on line that state, Ad Sitka Spruce AA 2. Website: https://musicvilla. Hello, As understand it, Sitka spruce is the typical top on a lot of guitars and I read a lot about the enhanced sound of upgrading I find Italian Alpine spruce to have a tone in between Sitka and Adirondack. ) before they can get the wood. Adirondack is an investment, a commitment that will continue to bear new surprises over the years, the decades and beyond. F. Sitka/Adirondack Spruce. pandachief. Today, w Common Name(s): Red Spruce, Adirondack Spruce Scientific Name: Picea rubens Distribution: Eastern North America Tree Size: 80-110 ft (24-34 m) tall, 2-4. Whether you're choosing a dreadnought, OM, or other size guitar, one question you might be asking yourself is: Adirondack or Sitka? Jordan compares two of th Sitka or adirondack General Acoustic Guitar Discussion The Acoustic Guitar Sitka vs adirondack spruce top for a martin oo 18. Registered User : Join Date: Aug 2016. Addy tops are I'd say get the less expensive option with the Engelmann spruce top. Lightweight: Despite its strength, Adirondack spruce is lightweight, which helps in keeping the overall weight of the guitar down while maintaining its structural integrity and responsiveness. The same species as European spruce, moon spruce is harvested at night according to the cycles of the moon. adirondack sort of demonstrates the clash between bright, crisp acoustic sounds, and warm, smooth, sweet sounds. I have two guitars with that top, a Gibson AJ and a Martin D28. Adirondack, or Eastern red spruce, named after its ruddy coloring, Italian spruce vs sitka spruce General Acoustic Guitar Discussion The Acoustic Guitar Forum > I've played/heard all representatives of the commonly used Spruce (Sitka, Engelmann, Adirondack, European) that sound ordinary and I've heard and played others that sounded amazing. Registered User : Join Date: Sep 2003. Can anyone tell me how the different woods might effect the so. Red Spruce debate is endless. • Moon spruce. 9 ft (4. ) One of my favorite top materials for fingerstyle is Italian Spruce. rubens is the spruce of the Adirondacks, so it seems that common name is as appropriate as a non-scientific name . Martin) were built with Adirondack. 67 74. The wood is also extremely European vs. The Adirondack spruce of the vintage era was much stiffer wood than Sitka spruce and was a better choice for guitar tops for that reason. Which do you think sounds best the traditional (sitka) or the up The Sitka vs Engelmann debate could go on and on - and no one would win because what sounds better to you, well it, sounds better to you. But all this happens with side and back wood, too. It’s also grown in abundance in North American forests, including in Canada and Alaska. My only acoustic is a Red spruce tends to have less highs than Euro, and an exaggerated midrange. Both Author Topic: Adirondack vs Sitka (Read 1345 times) Violeiro. While Alpine spruce closely resembles Sitka spruce, right down the middle tonally. , the thickness of the cut. ” Blending characteristics of Adirondack and Sitka, our European spruce’s rich tone and complexity make it highly versatile. Oftentimes, guitars are made using wood from spruce trees. I have guitars with both types of spruce and I would be more concerned with the quality of a given top set than its species. Adirondack spruce isn't automatically "better" every time, as I learned the hard way with the Adirondack-topped Both Sitka spruce and Adirondack spruce are excellent tonewoods for guitar tops, but they have distinct characteristics that can influence their suitability for fingerstyle playing. That appears to be much less likely if I were to use Sitka. American Spruce! 🌲Welcome to Tom Sands' channel, where we dive deep into the world of fine luthiery a I also have a Martin OM with sitka top and EIR side and back. Spruce: Sitka spruce, Engelmann spruce, and Adirondack spruce are among acoustic guitars' most commonly used top woods. Both have layered rosewood back/sides. P. A quick synopsis: Red spruce = heavy and stiff Sitka = heavy and less stiff Euro = light and stiff Engelmann = light and less stiff On paper, Euro spruce beats everything. 2,480 1,321. You hear what you want to hear! (or A lighter colored wood than Sitka Spruce, Engelmann Spruce shares the same tonal characteristics as a Sitka only with richer overtones and more focused mids. These species display significant differences in their appearance and characteristics. Two popular choices for this prized piece are Adirondack and Sitka spruce, each boasting distinct characteristics that resonate with different playing styles and tonal preferences. If you're on the hunt for your dream acoustic, A nearly extinct tonewood is making a glorious comeback: Adirondack spruce. Und schauen Sie sich auch Coen und Maarten an, die einen Martin D28 wmit Sitka und Adirondack vergleichen. by C. Spruce Tops: Adi vs. These qualities give Adirondack spruce top guitars a bit more volume and complexity while maintaining good clarity. Typically, Engelmann spruce is thought of as responding to a lighter touch and having a more pronounced midrange while sitka spruce is thought of as being better suited to a stronger touch and having a brighter tone. #5 since Adirondack spruce is relatively scarce, wood harvesters have to wait for an Adirondack tree to fall down naturally (in a storm, etc. I'd chose the latter any day, but that's just me. debate, but it's about each individual piece of wood. Both are Northfield S-Series mandos, but one has an Engelmann top and the other has an Adirondack t I thought it would be fun to compare these two mandolins! That being said, Englemann Spruce is a warmer tonewood, warmer than Sitka and will sound that way immediately when compared to Addy. It offers crisp, clean note separation with just enough complexity and warmth. I've heard some great ones made with Adirondack (European, too). Explore the rich tones of Taylor Guitars' Adirondack spruce acoustic guitars. Lutz Spruce (High Mountain Tonewoods) 4. Recently got to play a few Furch guitars while I was in Nashville, My favorite was a red pure series, but I don't know if I played the sitka or alpine spruce top version. However, they share characteristics, including evergreen needles, conical shapes, and cones growing on their branches. Not a totally accurate/fair comparison though, considering they're shaped differently, and have other construction differences. Which do you prefer, and why -- Adirondack spruce or Sitka spruce? Why does Adirondack spruce cost more? #2 07-13-2022, 10:53 AM Draft Guitar. On average red spruce is stiffer than sitka spruce. ; The Sitka spruce Carmanah Giant, located in Carmanah Walbran Provincial Park, is the tallest in Canada with a height of Interesting Facts. quake17. Location: Abingdon, Illinois. A naturally occurring hybrid of Sitka and White spruce, Lutz grows in climate zones between where Sitka and White spruce are found. So my opinions is that the EIR vs mahogany on side and back makes more difference than adirondack vs sitka on top. It will have different tonal characteristics than Sitka Spruce. Many boutique builders charge extra for Lutz spruce over Sitka spruce, although the premium may due in part to the fact that Lutz spruce trees don’t grow to be as large as Sitka spruce trees, so it’s harder to get pieces large enough to make guitar tops out of. It is also used in classical guitars. Adirondack Spruce. Spruce, whether it be sitka or adi, is going to produce a very similar tone. I can only recall playing one Taylor guitar with an Adirondack Spruce top on it: a Custom DN (Mahogany back/sides) that I was comparing to a 510 (which had an Engelmann Spruce top). Today, mature specimens of all the most popular spruce varieties are scarce. Most guitars use the Sitka spruce for their soundboard- in fact, about 80% of all guitars produced use Sitka spruce. #2 06-27-2024, 06:13 AM fpuhan. Today we compare Adirondack Spruce vs Sitka Spruce tops on 2 identical Martin HD-28 models. Part of what makes these spruces such phenomenally resonant woods—their slow rate of growth—also makes them susceptible to overharvest. Any of you wood aficionados have info on this variety? Thanks! IIRC, there is generally one species of spruce from Europe that has historically been used for guitars. Sitka spruce tends to be a bit denser and stiffer along the grain than European spruce, on the average, but it's not at all difficult to fine pieces of any species that are far higher or lower in density and stiffness than the 'average'. I have not had a lot of opportunities to play other AJ’s so trying to say what the difference is with RS vs Sitka is difficult but my ears hear a Sitka and Engelmann spruce have been better options for Taylors and we have been extremely happy with their sound and performance. And Sitka, the most democratic of tops, is the people’s sound, ready to play. 6-1. Swiss, or Carpathian and like any other species (Adirondack, Sitka and Engelmann), a set can be obtained that is exceptionally light and stiff with great tap tone Interesting Facts. Adirondack vs Sitka Bracing Materials: Sitka Spruce: Another common bracing wood, Sitka spruce is more abundant and generally less expensive than Adirondack. I'm intrigued by these E6OM-TC's. (Sitka grows in more coastal areas, while White spruce thrives in interior regions. 6 m). Old growth Sitka spruce has been virtually wiped out from its native range, as has much of the remaining Adirondack out East. That being said, I always prefer Engelmann or European spruce over Sitka, simply because of their extra warmth that tames the "spunkiness" of spruce. African Padauk Visually striking, African Padauk shares many tonal properties of traditional rosewoods, having warm and focused lows while having clear highs and with plenty of overtones. However, I've heard that you can have a piece of Englemann Spruce that is as heavy as an average Adirondack Spruce piece, while you can also have an Adirondack spruce top that is as light as an average European or Engelmann spruce top. Arguably the most common tonewood, Sitka is a well-rounded tonewood, one suited for many styles of playing. #12 12-18-2022, 11:34 AM Stevien. But what's different about it compared to Sitka? And is Adirondack better? In today's Martin Guitar video, Maury compares Sitka Spruce vs Adirondack Spruce. I have an OM guitar with red spruce, a Collings OM1A deep body, and I have two OM guitars with sitka spruce -- a Martin 000-28VS and a Santa Cruz OM/PW. a lot of folks claim they don't hear much of a difference between them and spruces grown in the U. Both are dreadnoug European has been long favored by classical guitar luthiers for its slightly darker tone. If you're on the hunt for your dream acoustic, Sitka almost always displays gorgeous silking across the grain. I have some Adi tops, Carpathian over Madi (000-42MEC) is amazing. Top. Here we compare and contrast the 2 unique sounds, When it comes to high-end acoustic guitars, the soundboard, often made of spruce, plays a crucial role in shaping the instrument's voice. Red spruce is more expensive, One of the characteristics of Adirondack VS Sitka is Adirondack take's a bit more time to open up. It’s “often compared to Engelmann, with a touch of cedar’s warmth. I am familiar with the thermo-cured process but, I am not familiar with Swiss Alpine spruce. 55 m) at breast height, trunk volume of 11,900 cu ft (337 m 3), and a height of 248 Italian Alpine Spruce vs Adirondack Spruce. I don't build flattop guitars with Sitka. Now, using Adirondack Spruce as the soundboard is another matter. Experience unparalleled tonewood sound quality today. Some questions for those more experienced than I What's the assumed affect to the tone of the same instrument (oval or f hole) resulting from the different wood? Do people generally believe that the Sitka vs Adirondack. Red/ Adirondack spruce is genetically distinct, separated by 2 million years of glaciation from its western cousins, and has intrinsically shorter medullary rays even when the European has been long favored by classical guitar luthiers for its slightly darker tone. Swiss spruce is another one we’ve seen here at Moore Music, and is very close tonally to Adirondack spruce. (Adirondack spruce top over mahogany) I feel the Adirondack top added a degree of sonic magic to the guitar versus the identical model with Sitka that I compared it to side-by-side. S. The Sitka spruce as a tonewood is inexpensive yet ensures you have versatility when playing. Adirondack vs Engelman Spruce? Nobody can tell you which top will sound best to YOU, but I can say that using different brands (or tensions) I have several guitars with Sitka tops, a few with cedar tops, and one with an Englemann top. Charter Member : Join Date: Aug 2013. At least Martin believes there is a difference between Italian, German, and Carpathian. Sitka spruce VS Adirondack to accompany vocals General Acoustic Guitar Discussion The Sitka vs. Both are the same in all regards except for the top wood. Engelmann General Acoustic Guitar Discussion The Acoustic Guitar Forum > General especially in adirondack and Carpathian spruce - another choice for you to consider. had an opportunity, over the past month or so, to audition quite a few guitars with European spruce tops. Johnny Canso. Adirondack has the most headroom of all the spruces, but I would never commission a new guitar with a Sitka top when red or German spruce was available. Sitka Spruce- Revisited: When a person buys or acquires a guitar, they’re getting a finely crafted instrument that was made from various materials, including wood. Adirondack spruce is, or maybe should be, "was" better. Like Adirondack and Sitka spruce, European spruce sits in the magic zone of being lightweight and extremely stiff. I'm looking into purchasing a 2012 D-18 with either a Sitka or Adirondack spruce top. Location: Northern Virginia, USA. I know there have been many posts about Red/Adirondack spruce, Englemann, Sitka, but rarely any on the Euro spruces. Just my opinion. Spruce vs Koa top General Acoustic Guitar Discussion The Acoustic Yes, the average for one type may be a bit this way or that way from the others, and hence we wind up with all this Adirondack vs. The strings used, True Vintage J-45 Sitka Top vs adirondack Top True Vintage J-45 Sitka Top vs adirondack Top. g. Full Member; Posts: 107; Re: Adirondack vs Sitka Do you mean Sitka Spruce vs Adirondack Spruce? Adirondack over mahagony sounds too dry and too bright to my ears. (aside from Englemann). I've seen mandolin models supposedly "upgraded" from a Sitka spruce top to an Adirondack spruce top, for about $200 in a ~$1100 retail price mandolin. #3 12-09-2005, 11:04 AM Fngrstyl. Sitka vs. Marked as Swiss Spruce 3. Adirondack spruce? Adirondack (red spruce) has a lot of fundamental with beautiful overtones. Louis, MO helps us answer this tough question. Something else we see often in German Spruce vs Adirondack vs Sitka. This is partially due to it wide availability, large diameter logs and high yield. All European spruce belongs to the species picea abies, whether it’s Italian, Swiss, Carpathian or Norwegian. Sitka and See more Two in particular, the Adirondack Spruce [Red Spruce from the Adirondack region of upstate New York] and the Sitka Spruce, are beloved by guitar makers as they produce the Two popular choices for this prized piece are Adirondack and Sitka spruce, each boasting distinct characteristics that resonate with different playing styles and tonal preferences. I'm having a hard time finding much info on tonal differences between the two spruce species. There a lot of talk about Adirondack Red Spruce and how it is the gold standard for tops (seems to be the rage). 5 ft (. com To me, Red Spruce can sound almost strident at times, or in other words, too harsh (especially when paired with Mahogany). I've heard a lot of good Sitka flattop guitars, but I can't recall hearing a great one. AkWingnut. But that's just one singer with a 3-guitar sample. The bottom line there is that, Sitka vs. By mking November 23, 2009 When it comes to tonal differences, back and side woods really stand out (rosewood vs. These are all excellent guitars. I personally wouldn't care which was used on a guitar of mine. Hi, I have a couple Martins with Engelmann spruce tops and one with Adirondack spruce top and one with sitka spruce. Sitka hat verschiedene Vorteile. Posts: 2,490 Adirondack Spruce European Spruce. I view Italian Alpine Spruce as being the best of both worlds between Adirondack and Sitka. Due to heavy deforestation, it was not available in good supply for a number of years. Here’s a breakdown of their differences and how they relate to fingerstyle guitar: Sitka Spruce (Picea sitchensis) Tone: Balanced, warm, and slightly compressed Sitka Spruce: Sitka is the standard wood for steel-string guitars. I have a Martin guitar and three Gibson guitars all with a Sitka spruce top. Sitka is very warm and sweet sounding but the notes to my ears are not as articulate and the new guitars have not had the Sitka Spruce is widely used for steel string acoustic guit In this video we are compare two Spruce species - Sitka Spruce and German Spruce for guitar tops. ADI Red Spruce (Group Buy) Kim Strode Daylesford, Australia. Post Dec 30, 2017 #3 2017-12-30T15:37+00:00. For example, most high-quality pre-war guitars (e. Sitka Spruce. com for more information. My interest is in building great guitars if I can. ) Lutz has is considered very adaptive within those microclimates, which can yield properties that are superior to either species As a guitar geek do you ever find yourself pondering the question, “What is the difference between Sitka and Adirondack spruce braces?” Acoustic Tuesday correspondent Matt Chulka from Eddie’s Guitars in St. Here we have a standard series Martin OM-28 with Sitka Spruce top & braces, compared to a Whether you're choosing a dreadnought, OM, or other size guitar, one question you might be asking yourself is: Adirondack or Sitka? Jordan compares two of the most Adi is one of the stiffest - excellent projection, power and resonance. It's easy for me to hear the difference between mahogany and rosewood, but not so much between red spruce and sitka and I have examples of both, though they are on Sitka vs. Englemann, etc. Unless you're considering Gifford Pinchot's 1898 tract on the "Adirondack Spruce" (which he clearly identifies as red spruce, AKA Picea rubens), it seems the term Adirondack spruce is used exclusively by the lutherie community, and by no one else. Sitka is a lot cheaper than European spruce, which is cheaper again than Adirondack spruce. I am a fan of Red Spruce. It's a great choice for guitarists with a more aggressive playing style. Charter Member : Join Date: Jun 2021. mahogany). For our 20th Anniversary, we asked the Martin Custom Shop to build us some 'standards' with an Adirondack Spruce top and Adirondack Spruce bracings. Our review and side by side comparison of Lowden F50c Models with Adirondack Spruce and Alpine Spruce tops. That works about the same for singing as the EIR dread with adirondack. As you all may already know, I just purchased a Collings OM1A. 3,623 1,355. 🌲 Discover the Ultimate Showdown: European Spruce vs. jefmz bejere euncsy vay jfds aacfbf kol qvlqfks rilz zbbxwvwo lhhxwt pkyid bczmk caezl yyogjhf